shipslides
Philosophy14 slides2 views

Aesthetics — Deck 08

A philosophical gallery of beauty, taste, and art — across three centuries of careful argument and an even longer tradition of looking.

StandaloneDownload
Sandboxed deck
Open raw
Shared with ShipslidesCreate your own deck →

About this HTML presentation

This Shipslides page presents Aesthetics — Deck 08 as an interactive HTML presentation deck in the Philosophy catalog with 14 slides. The share page keeps the uploaded deck sandboxed while exposing readable context, topics, and a slide outline for viewers and search engines.

A philosophical gallery of beauty, taste, and art — across three centuries of careful argument and an even longer tradition of looking. Key sections include: Aes thet ics; Three questions, repeatedly; Plato & the suspicion of art; Hume — Of the Standard of Taste, 1757; Kant — Critique of the Power of Judgment, 1790; Nietzsche — The Birth of Tragedy, 1872; Formalism & Significant Form; Expression Theories; What is Art?; The Gallery.

Key sections

  • 01Aes thet ics
  • 02Three questions, repeatedly
  • 03Plato & the suspicion of art
  • 04Hume — Of the Standard of Taste, 1757
  • 05Kant — Critique of the Power of Judgment, 1790
  • 06Nietzsche — The Birth of Tragedy, 1872
  • 07Formalism & Significant Form
  • 08Expression Theories
  • 09What is Art?
  • 10The Gallery
  • 11Key Works
  • 12Why It Still Matters
  • 13Go Deeper
  • 14Colophon

Topics covered

philosophyaesthetics

Related decks

Philosophy13 slides

Aesthetics — What Makes a Thing Beautiful?

Philosophy30 slides

Stoicism

Philosophy15 slides

Ancient Greek Philosophy — Deck 01

Philosophy14 slides

Eastern Philosophy — Deck 02

Slide outline
  1. 01Aes thet ics
  2. 02Three questions, repeatedly
  3. 03Plato & the suspicion of art
  4. 04Hume — Of the Standard of Taste, 1757
  5. 05Kant — Critique of the Power of Judgment, 1790
  6. 06Nietzsche — The Birth of Tragedy, 1872
  7. 07Formalism & Significant Form
  8. 08Expression Theories
  9. 09What is Art?
  10. 10The Gallery
  11. 11Key Works
  12. 12Why It Still Matters
  13. 13Go Deeper
  14. 14Colophon
Page data
Canonical
https://shipslides.com/d/philosophy-aesthetics
Category
Philosophy
Size
37.3 KB
Updated
2026-05-17
LLM text
https://shipslides.com/d/philosophy-aesthetics/llms.txt

Presentation Transcript

Detailed slide-by-slide text content extracted from this presentation.

Slide 01

Aesthetics

  • VIII · 01 / 14
  • DECK 08 · GALLERY VIII
  • A philosophical gallery of beauty, taste, and art — across three centuries of careful argument and an even longer tradition of looking.
Slide 02

Three questions, repeatedly

  • VIII · 02 / 14
  • Aesthetics, as a self-conscious branch of philosophy, gets its name from Alexander Baumgarten in 1735 — though the questions are very old. Three of them recur:
  • What is beauty? A property of objects, a response of subjects, or something between?
  • What is art? A class of objects, a class of activities, an institution? Can the question be answered at all?
  • What is taste? The capacity to discriminate aesthetically. Is it cultivated or innate? Subjective or trained?
  • This deck is a small gallery in twelve rooms. The rooms are arranged thematically rather than chronologically. We start with the Enlightenment — Hume on the standard of taste, Kant on disinterested judgment — and end with twentieth-century arguments about formalism, expression, and definition.
  • Walk slowly. Each painting will keep its argument.
  • Beauty
  • PLATO · KANT
  • Taste
  • HUME · BOURDIEU
  • Form
  • BELL · GREENBERG
  • Expression
  • CROCE · COLLINGWOOD
Slide 03

Plato & the suspicion of art

  • VIII · 03 / 14
  • The first systematic Western philosophy of art is also a critique of it. In Republic Books III and X, Plato argues that imitative art (mimesis) is twice removed from reality: a couch made by a carpenter is a copy of the Form of the couch; a painted couch is a copy of the carpenter's. Worse, art appeals to the lower part of the soul and inflames the passions.
  • This is why poets are exiled from the ideal city in Republic X — though Plato himself was a great writer of dramatic dialogue, and his Symposium contains one of the most beautiful theories of beauty in any language.
  • The ladder of beauty — Symposium 210a–212a
  • Diotima teaches Socrates: one ascends from the love of a single beautiful body, to the love of all beautiful bodies, to the love of beautiful minds, to beautiful institutions and laws, to beautiful knowledge — and finally to beauty itself: eternal, uncreated, the cause of every other beautiful thing.
  • Aristotle's reply
  • In the Poetics (c. 335 BCE), Aristotle defends mimesis. Imitation is natural to humans; we learn through it. Tragedy effects a katharsis of pity and fear — a purging or clarification (the word is contested) — through the depiction of serious actions.
  • Aristotle's six elements of tragedy, in order of importance: plot, character, thought, diction, song, spectacle. The ranking would surprise a Hollywood producer.
  • Beauty is a matter of size and order, and therefore impossible either (1) in a very minute creature, since our perception becomes indistinct as it approaches instantaneity; or (2) in a creature of vast size...
  • Aristotle, Poetics 7
Slide 04

Hume — Of the Standard of Taste, 1757

  • VIII · 04 / 14
  • David Hume · 1711 — 1776 · Edinburgh
  • Beauty is no quality in things themselves: it exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty.
  • Hume, Of the Standard of Taste
  • Hume's essay starts from radical subjectivism — beauty is in the mind — and asks whether anything like a standard of taste is nonetheless possible. His answer: yes, but only by appeal to the verdicts of true judges.
  • Five conditions of the true judge
  • Strong sense — undiminished organs of perception.
  • Delicate sentiment — sensitivity to fine distinctions.
  • Practice — repeated exposure and comparison.
  • Comparison — wide acquaintance with other works of art.
  • Freedom from prejudice — willingness to set aside personal and cultural bias.
  • "Where these are united in any one, they form the true judge in the finer arts; and the joint verdict of such, wherever they are to be found, is the true standard of taste and beauty."
  • Two unsolved difficulties Hume frankly acknowledges:
  • Different ages and temperaments will value different things even among true judges. (Hume's "innocent" preference for grave Roman comedy over light French comedy.)
  • Some moral or religious content is, for Hume, an "unavoidable blemish" — the mores of the original audience can put a barrier between us and the work.
  • A circle: the standard is set by true judges; true judges are recognised by their agreement with the standard. Hume thinks the circle is virtuous; many readers think it is vicious. The argument is alive.
Slide 05

Kant — Critique of the Power of Judgment, 1790

  • VIII · 05 / 14
  • Immanuel Kant · 1724 — 1804 · Königsberg
  • The third Kritik, after the Critique of Pure Reason and the Critique of Practical Reason, completes Kant's system. The first half ("Critique of Aesthetic Judgment") gives the most influential analysis of beauty in the modern tradition.
  • The four moments of the beautiful
  • Quality: a judgment of taste is disinterested — pleasure that does not depend on the existence of the object.
  • Quantity: a judgment of taste claims universal assent without a concept — when I say "this is beautiful," I speak as if for everyone.
  • Relation: the beautiful exhibits purposiveness without a purpose — it appears organised as if for an end, but no specific end determines it.
  • Modality: the judgment claims necessary connection of pleasure with the object — under appropriate conditions, all should agree.
  • The free play of the faculties
  • What grounds these claims? Not a concept — beauty is not the application of a rule. Rather, in encountering a beautiful object, the imagination and the understanding fall into a "free play," each sustaining the other without subsuming the object under any determinate concept. Kant calls this the harmony of the faculties.
  • The sublime
  • Distinguished from the beautiful. The mathematical sublime: starry skies, vast deserts — the imagination fails to comprehend the magnitude. The dynamical sublime: storms, mountains — physical power that would overwhelm us, contemplated from safety. Both reveal a power in us greater than nature: the moral idea.
  • Two things fill the mind with ever new and increasing admiration and awe... the starry heavens above me and the moral law within me.
  • Kant, Critique of Practical Reason, conclusion
Slide 06

Nietzsche — The Birth of Tragedy, 1872

  • VIII · 06 / 14
  • Friedrich Nietzsche · 1844 — 1900
  • Nietzsche's first book, written when he was 27 and a professor of classical philology in Basel. Greek tragedy, he argues, was born from the union of two divine principles: Apollonian form, individuation, dream — and Dionysian ecstasy, dissolution, intoxication. Tragedy lets us look into the abyss without being destroyed because Apollonian form contains Dionysian truth.
  • Socrates, Nietzsche argues, killed tragedy by replacing the Dionysian with rational dialectic. Euripides did the murder; Socrates wrote the warrant.
  • Art as the highest task of life
  • "Only as an aesthetic phenomenon is existence and the world eternally justified." (BT §5) Nietzsche means it. In the absence of metaphysical or religious justification, what redeems life is its artistic shaping — by the artist, of the work; by each of us, of ourselves.
Slide 07

Formalism & Significant Form

  • VIII · 07 / 14
  • Clive Bell — Art, 1914
  • The Bloomsbury critic Clive Bell proposes that the property in virtue of which something is a work of visual art is "significant form" — the disposition of lines and colours that produces a special "aesthetic emotion" in the viewer.
  • "Lines and colours combined in a particular way, certain forms and relations of forms, stir our aesthetic emotions. These relations and combinations of lines and colours, these aesthetically moving forms, I call 'significant form'." (Art, ch. 1)
  • Greenberg & modernist painting
  • Clement Greenberg's mid-century essays argue that each art form has its own essence — for painting, flatness — and that modernism is the progressive purification of each art toward its essential medium. Pollock, Newman, Rothko deliver the painting that is most fully and only painting.
  • The trouble
  • The aesthetic emotion is defined as that which is produced by significant form; significant form is defined as that which produces the aesthetic emotion. The Bell circle is even more brazen than Hume's. Critics from Susanne Langer onward asked, fairly, whether anything had been said.
  • And the formalist programme has trouble with art that depends on context, narrative, or political content. Is Goya's The Third of May a great painting because of its formal relations alone? Most viewers would not care to be told that the bullets and the kneeling figure were beside the formal point.
  • Anti-formalism
  • Reaction came from many directions. Arthur Danto's The Transfiguration of the Commonplace (1981) used Andy Warhol's Brillo boxes to argue that art is constituted partly by its theoretical interpretation, not by appearance alone.
Slide 08

Expression Theories

  • VIII · 08 / 14
  • Art as the embodiment of feeling. The opposing tradition.
  • Tolstoy
  • Tolstoy — What Is Art?, 1898
  • EXPRESSION · INFECTION
  • "Art is a human activity consisting in this, that one man consciously, by means of certain external signs, hands on to others feelings he has lived through, and that other people are infected by these feelings and also experience them."
  • Croce
  • Croce — Aesthetic, 1902
  • INTUITION · EXPRESSION
  • Art is intuition, intuition is expression. The artwork lives in the artist's mind; the physical object is a memory aid. Critics object that this collapses art into private mental events.
  • Collingwood
  • Collingwood — Principles of Art, 1938
  • CLARIFICATION OF EMOTION
  • Art proper is the imaginative expression of emotion; the artist comes to know what they feel by making the work. Distinguished from craft (means to a pre-given end) and amusement (arousal of pre-given feelings).
Slide 09

What is Art?

  • VIII · 09 / 14
  • The definitional question gets sharper after Duchamp's Fountain (1917) — a urinal signed "R. Mutt." If that is art, what isn't? Twentieth-century answers fall into a few families.
  • TheoryProposed byWhat it saysTrouble
  • MimeticPlato, AristotleArt imitates reality.Music? Abstract painting?
  • ExpressionTolstoy, Croce, CollingwoodArt expresses emotion.Formal abstract works; conceptual art.
  • FormalistBell, FryArt has significant form.Circular; struggles with narrative content.
  • InstitutionalDickie (1974)Art is what is conferred status as art by the artworld.Risks circularity; conservative.
  • HistoricalLevinson, CarrollArt is what is intended for regard in the manner of past art.Vague at the boundary.
  • Cluster accountBerys GautMany criteria; no single one necessary or sufficient.Disjunctive; loses unity.
  • Anti-essentialistWeitz (1956)"Art" is an open concept; no definition possible.Why so much fits the family resemblance?
  • Most working philosophers of art today take some hybrid view. The Duchamp problem is real; we know Fountain was art (because it is, now, in the Tate Modern); the question is which features secured that status, and whether the same features could secure it for, say, a banana taped to a wall (Cattelan, 2019). The conversation continues.
Slide 10

The Gallery

  • VIII · 10 / 14
  • A modern museum is a working machine for aesthetic judgment. The wall labels do quiet metaphysical work: this is a painting; this is by Cézanne; this is from his late period; this is on loan from a private collection. By the time you stand before it, dozens of choices have already framed your seeing. Aesthetics is in part the study of those choices.
Slide 11

Key Works

  • VIII · 11 / 14
  • AuthorWorkYearNote
  • PlatoSymposium · Republic X · Hippias Majorc. 380 BCEladder of beauty; mimesis
  • AristotlePoeticsc. 335 BCEtragedy, katharsis
  • PlotinusEnneads I.6c. 250 CEbeauty as the One shining through
  • BurkeA Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful1757sublime/beautiful distinction
  • HumeOf the Standard of Taste1757true judges
  • KantCritique of the Power of Judgment1790third critique
  • SchillerOn the Aesthetic Education of Man1795play drive
  • HegelLectures on Fine Art1818–29art as sensuous embodiment of the Idea
  • NietzscheThe Birth of Tragedy1872Apollonian/Dionysian
  • TolstoyWhat Is Art?1898infection theory
  • BellArt1914significant form
  • Heidegger"The Origin of the Work of Art"1935truth happening
  • AdornoAesthetic Theory1970, posth.art's negative critique
  • DickieArt and the Aesthetic1974institutional theory
  • DantoThe Transfiguration of the Commonplace1981artworld; embodied meaning
  • BourdieuDistinction1979sociology of taste
  • ScrutonThe Aesthetics of Music1997musical understanding
Slide 12

Why It Still Matters

  • VIII · 12 / 14
  • Aesthetics has, in our time, swelled to take in everyday life: the ethics of how we dress, how cities look, how interfaces feel. "Aesthetic capitalism" (Reckwitz, Boltanski) describes the way taste has become the engine of large parts of the economy.
  • Generative image models have made the question of authorship aesthetically vivid in a way the gallery-going public is meeting for the first time. Who is the author of a Midjourney image — the prompter, the model, the trainers, the photographers whose work fed the dataset? Each candidate answer is a chapter of aesthetics.
  • And the older questions go on. Whether beauty is in the object or the eye; whether the standard of taste is a standard or a mood; whether art is what some institution says it is, or what makes us feel a way no other thing can — these are the questions Diotima asked Socrates on a couch in a drinking party in 416 BCE.
  • The objects change. The questions change less than they appear to.
Slide 13

Go Deeper

  • VIII · 13 / 14
  • The BBC's In Our Time has a fine episode on Kant's Critique of Judgment; Crash Course Philosophy covers aesthetics in two episodes; the Khan Academy "Smarthistory" series is the closest thing to a free art-history degree.
  • Watch · BBC In Our Time · Aesthetics
  • Watch · Crash Course Philosophy · Aesthetics
  • Further reading
  • Monroe Beardsley · Aesthetics: Problems in the Philosophy of Criticism (1958)
  • Arthur Danto · The Transfiguration of the Commonplace (1981)
  • Kendall Walton · Mimesis as Make-Believe (1990)
  • Roger Scruton · Beauty (2009)
  • Berys Gaut · Art, Emotion and Ethics (2007)
Slide 14

Colophon

  • VIII · 14 / 14
  • Beauty will save the world.
  • Dostoevsky, The Idiot, 1869 — though the book is more sceptical than the slogan
Remove this deck