shipslides
Philosophy13 slides0 views

Aesthetics — What Makes a Thing Beautiful?

What makes a thing beautiful?

StandaloneDownload
Sandboxed deck
Open raw
Shared with ShipslidesCreate your own deck →

About this HTML presentation

This Shipslides page presents Aesthetics — What Makes a Thing Beautiful? as an interactive HTML presentation deck in the Philosophy catalog with 13 slides. The share page keeps the uploaded deck sandboxed while exposing readable context, topics, and a slide outline for viewers and search engines.

What makes a thing beautiful? Key sections include: AESTHETICS; Plato Beauty as a Form; Aristotle Mimesis & Catharsis; David Hume Of the Standard of Taste; Immanuel Kant Purposiveness Without Purpose; The Sublime Beauty + Awe + Terror; The Romantic Turn Beauty in the Wild & the Strange; Leo Tolstoy Art as Emotional Infection; Modernism Art for Art's Sake; The Institutional Theory The Artworld Decides.

Key sections

  • 01AESTHETICS
  • 02Plato Beauty as a Form
  • 03Aristotle Mimesis & Catharsis
  • 04David Hume Of the Standard of Taste
  • 05Immanuel Kant Purposiveness Without Purpose
  • 06The Sublime Beauty + Awe + Terror
  • 07The Romantic Turn Beauty in the Wild & the Strange
  • 08Leo Tolstoy Art as Emotional Infection
  • 09Modernism Art for Art's Sake
  • 10The Institutional Theory The Artworld Decides
  • 11Cross-cultural Aesthetics Other Standards, Other Eyes
  • 12The Present Crisis AI & the Cheap Beautiful Image
  • 13For Further Looking References & Lectures

Topics covered

catalogphilosophyaesthetics

Related decks

Philosophy14 slides

Aesthetics — Deck 08

Philosophy13 slides

Greek Philosophy — from Thales to the Stoics

Philosophy13 slides

Eastern Philosophy — The Long Traditions

Philosophy14 slides

The Enlightenment — Reason against Tradition

Slide outline
  1. 01AESTHETICS
  2. 02Plato Beauty as a Form
  3. 03Aristotle Mimesis & Catharsis
  4. 04David Hume Of the Standard of Taste
  5. 05Immanuel Kant Purposiveness Without Purpose
  6. 06The Sublime Beauty + Awe + Terror
  7. 07The Romantic Turn Beauty in the Wild & the Strange
  8. 08Leo Tolstoy Art as Emotional Infection
  9. 09Modernism Art for Art's Sake
  10. 10The Institutional Theory The Artworld Decides
  11. 11Cross-cultural Aesthetics Other Standards, Other Eyes
  12. 12The Present Crisis AI & the Cheap Beautiful Image
  13. 13For Further Looking References & Lectures
Page data
Canonical
https://shipslides.com/d/catalog-philosophy-aesthetics
Category
Philosophy
Size
27.5 KB
Updated
2026-05-17
LLM text
https://shipslides.com/d/catalog-philosophy-aesthetics/llms.txt

Presentation Transcript

Detailed slide-by-slide text content extracted from this presentation.

Slide 01

AESTHETICS

  • Plate I
  • Philosophy Series — Volume IX
  • What makes a thing beautiful?
  • A thirteen-slide gallery
  • — after the plaques —
Slide 02

PlatoBeauty as a Form

  • Plate II
  • c. 380 BCE — Athens
  • For Plato, the beautiful things we encounter — a face, a temple, a melody — are only shadows. What they share is a participation in Beauty itself: an eternal, perfect Form, glimpsed by the soul before birth.
  • He who has been instructed thus far in the things of love, and who has learned to see the beautiful in due order and succession, when he comes toward the end will suddenly perceive a nature of wondrous beauty.
  • — Symposium, 210e
  • Aesthetic experience, then, is recognition — the soul remembering what it has always known. Beauty draws us upward, away from sense and toward truth.
Slide 03

AristotleMimesis & Catharsis

  • Plate III
  • c. 335 BCE — The Lyceum
  • Aristotle returns beauty to the earth. Art is mimesis — imitation — and we delight in well-made imitations even of ugly things. The corpse pictured well is pleasing; the corpse itself is not.
  • Tragedy works on us through pity and fear, producing catharsis: a clarifying purge of the emotions. Beauty here is not transcendence but psychological alignment — proportion, unity, completeness.
Slide 04

David HumeOf the Standard of Taste

  • Plate IV
  • 1757 — Edinburgh
  • If beauty is in the eye of the beholder, why does anyone bother arguing about it? Hume notices that we don't actually treat taste as wholly relative. Some critics are better than others.
  • Strong sense, united to delicate sentiment, improved by practice, perfected by comparison, and cleared of all prejudice — can alone entitle critics to this valuable character.
  • — Of the Standard of Taste, 1757
  • Beauty is a felt response, but the standard is the convergent verdict of qualified judges across time. Homer survives. Most poets do not.
Slide 05

Immanuel KantPurposiveness Without Purpose

  • Plate V
  • 1790 — Königsberg
  • Kant's Critique of Judgment performs the great balancing act. The judgment "this rose is beautiful" is subjective — it reports a feeling, not a property. Yet when I make it, I claim universal assent: I expect you to agree.
  • Disinterested — pleasure unattached to want or use.
  • Universal — felt as if it must hold for everyone.
  • Purposive without purpose — designed-feeling without serving any end.
  • Necessary — we feel everyone ought to see it too.
  • The free play of imagination and understanding — beauty as the harmony of our own faculties.
Slide 06

The SublimeBeauty + Awe + Terror

  • Plate VI
  • Burke 1757 · Kant 1790
  • A thunderstorm at sea. The dome of the sky from a mountain pass. The face of a glacier.
  • Where beauty soothes and proportions, the sublime overwhelms. The faculties are temporarily defeated — and from that defeat, paradoxically, comes a kind of exaltation. We feel our smallness, and then our capacity to think the infinite that crushes us.
  • Two things fill the mind with ever new and increasing admiration and awe — the starry heavens above me and the moral law within me.
  • — Kant
Slide 07

The Romantic TurnBeauty in the Wild & the Strange

  • Plate VII
  • c. 1800 — Jena, Lake District
  • If the classical tradition prized symmetry, finish, and the ideal, the Romantics inverted nearly every value. Beauty migrates to:
  • the fragment rather than the whole;
  • the ruin rather than the temple intact;
  • the untamed landscape over the formal garden;
  • the peculiar face over the regular one;
  • the solitary genius over the trained craftsman.
  • "There is no exquisite beauty," wrote Bacon — and Poe later quoted him — "without some strangeness in the proportion."
Slide 08

Leo TolstoyArt as Emotional Infection

  • Plate VIII
  • 1897 — Yasnaya Polyana
  • In What Is Art?, Tolstoy bulldozes the Kantian edifice. Beauty is the wrong question. Art is whatever transmits feeling — whatever infects one human with the emotion of another.
  • Art is a human activity consisting in this — that one man consciously, by means of certain external signs, hands on to others feelings he has lived through, and that other people are infected by these feelings, and also experience them.
  • — What Is Art?, 1897
  • By this measure, a peasant lullaby may be greater art than a Beethoven symphony. The criterion is sincerity, clarity, and the universality of the feeling transmitted — not refinement, not novelty.
Slide 09

ModernismArt for Art's Sake

  • Plate IX
  • c. 1860 – c. 1960
  • L'art pour l'art — the slogan of Théophile Gautier — declared that art needed no moral, no narrative, no use. The painting is not a window onto something else; it is a flat surface covered with paint in a certain order.
  • Clement Greenberg pushed this further: each medium should investigate what is essential to itself. Painting becomes about flatness. Music about pure sound. The work refuses to be about anything but its own form.
  • Form is content. Content is form.
Slide 10

The Institutional TheoryThe Artworld Decides

  • Plate X
  • Dickie 1974 · Duchamp 1917
  • In 1917, Marcel Duchamp signed "R. Mutt" on a porcelain urinal and submitted it to an exhibition. The committee refused it. He had made his point.
  • George Dickie's response: stop trying to define art by intrinsic properties. An artwork is an artifact upon which some person or persons acting on behalf of the artworld has conferred the status of candidate for appreciation.
  • A urinal in a plumbing shop is plumbing. The same urinal in a gallery is art — because the artworld has spoken.
Slide 11

Cross-cultural AestheticsOther Standards, Other Eyes

  • Plate XI
  • Beyond the Western Frame
  • Wabi-sabi (Japan) — beauty in impermanence, asymmetry, the patina of use; the chipped tea bowl repaired with gold (kintsugi) is more beautiful for its breaks.
  • Qi (China) — in painting and calligraphy, the work succeeds when it carries a living energy or breath; technical precision without qi is dead.
  • African sculpture — long misread by European eyes as "primitive," then plundered for Cubist innovation; the carvings carried sophisticated systems of proportion, abstraction, and ritual function that the Western frame could not see.
  • No single grammar of beauty. But many grammars, each internally rigorous, each with its own qualified judges.
Slide 12

The Present CrisisAI & the Cheap Beautiful Image

  • Plate XII
  • 2022 →
  • For most of human history, the production of a "beautiful image" required years of training and hours of labor. That bottleneck is gone. A diffusion model produces a competent, often striking image in seconds, on demand, infinitely.
  • If beauty is the property the eye reports, AI floods the world with beauty. If beauty was always also traces of human intention, struggle, and choice — then the new images may be lovely and yet not, in the older sense, art at all.
  • When the supply curve goes vertical, what survives?
  • Provenance — who made it, and how.
  • Particularity — the marks of a specific life.
  • Risk — the possibility of failure that AI does not feel.
  • The institutional verdict — once again, the artworld will decide.
Slide 13

For Further LookingReferences & Lectures

  • Plate XIII
  • Coda
  • Beauty is what we have not yet finished arguing about.
  • Plato — Symposium, Phaedrus
  • Aristotle — Poetics
  • David Hume — Of the Standard of Taste (1757)
  • Immanuel Kant — Critique of the Power of Judgment (1790)
  • Edmund Burke — A Philosophical Enquiry into the Sublime and Beautiful (1757)
  • Leo Tolstoy — What Is Art? (1897)
  • George Dickie — Art and the Aesthetic (1974)
  • Leonard Koren — Wabi-Sabi for Artists, Designers, Poets & Philosophers (1994)
  • Lectures on YouTube:
  • Kant on Aesthetics
  • Duchamp's Fountain
  • — end of exhibition —
Remove this deck